Showing posts with label Recommend: (2/5) Don't Bother. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Recommend: (2/5) Don't Bother. Show all posts

Wednesday, 29 August 2012

Hokkaido Dairy Farm Milk Restaurant: Long queue here? DAFUQ?


Shop info:
Hokkaido Dairy Farm Milk Restaurant
Shop D1, G/F, Far East Finance Centre, 16 Harcourt Road, Admiralty

Various dates, lunch
~$50 per head

This is a restaurant that I fail to comprehend.  Like Bentopia downstairs, I looked forward to the opening of this place, tried it in its first few days of business, liked it, and eventually not returning as quality deteriorated.  YET, countless office workers queue along the bridge connecting Queensway Plaza and Far East Centre, sometimes stretching all the way across, for a takeaway cha siu rice with fried egg.  Baffling.

THE ENVIRONMENT

There frankly isn't much of an environment to speak of.  The dining area is tiny compared to the large office population that frequents this restaurant and it is near impossible to find a seat despite fast turnover time.  A row of high table seats faces a busy path along the shop front (yes, you'd be watching and watched by the office lunch crowd as you eat) and more normal tables lies behind.  Decor was bright and rather comfortable but completely ruined by the proximity to the crowd.

This is a place where you'd at most like to have a quick lunch during its busy hours and not to linger any longer than necessary.

THE SERVICE

There isn't much service to talk about, and what would you expect - this is a busy cha chaan teng.  That said, the ordering process is strange and perplexing, which does deserve some mention.

At most restaurants, when you what to take away your food, you tell the cashier guy / girl that it's a takeaway after you place the order.  Here, you must tell them before the order - a rather awkward habit that takes time to get used to.  Then, you must wait.  As the staffing and kitchen space afforded by this restaurant is not sufficient to cope with such a large lunch crowd, you can be sure as hell that the wait would be long and uncomfortable.  What else would you expect, blocking the path on one of the busier routes in Admiralty?

Then there is the "I don't give a damn, bugger off" attitude by the staff.  I once had to stand there and wait without a number and with my order hanging in the air - because the cashier girl made a mistake with my order and couldn't be asked to fix it, and instead continued to serve others when I was told to wait.  On another occasion, breakfast service was cancelled since the key holding staff couldn't get up to get to work.  How brilliant is that?

THE FOOD

Back when I still visit Hokkaido Dairy Farm, the only real option for lunch was the "Otaru" BBQ Pork Rice.  Now for those unwilling to read my bickering on this so-called BBQ pork:  It's crap.  Period.

To begin with, I do not understand how "Otaru" is a pile of poorly made chaa siu - it is not Japanese style chaa siu.  Obviously, the owners of the restaurant chain wants to make their products sound Japanese so they can charge more for exoticness, or maybe it was intended as a suggestion for quality which it somply doesn't have.  The meat itself is consistently tough and chewy across a few visits, as demonstrated by the photo below.

Tough.

Then, as suggested by the use of sauce on the chaa siu, the meat itself was rather tasteless.  So bad, actually, that the restaurant has to add flavour via the overpowering and salty sauce.

A mess.

Worse still, the chopping up of the chaa siu was horrid.  Usually in siu mei shops the chaa siu can be reassembled into a whole piece and are laid down accordingly.  Not here.  The "Otaru" chaa siu always seems to have been butchered with an unbelievably blunt hatchet, ran over by a truck then with the remaining pieced picked back up to serve.  Although it's probably not, it always felt like it is made up of leftover bits and pieces.

Poorly made scrambled egg.

Oh, and did I say that you can order it with scrambled egg?  If you do, there could be two outcomes:  1) they'd still give you a fried egg despite what they input into their system, as shown in first photo below, or 2) you'd get a scrambled egg that hasn't been properly mixed - with white bits in it.  More often than not the surface would be overcooked despite having a "flowing" core.  It's obvious that the chef wasn't putting much effort...

Scrambled-turned-fried egg.  Note that the receipt says scrambled!

At $39 plus at least 15 minutes of wait, this is by no means cheap.  The now closed siu mei shop used to serve a far superior chaa siu rice at much lower price.  Oh, and if you come after 12 noon, the queue would be so long that it'd be more like a 30 min wait.

So I couldn't help but ask... what are these people queueing for?  The fun of it?

CONCLUSION

On price alone, not expensive, but if waiting time and quality is taken into consideration, a ripoff.  Even if it is worth the $39 price tag, which I don't think it is, it is not worth the wait.

Summary (rated 1-5):
FOOD:  (2/5)  "Otaru" chaa siu is quite bad.
SERVICE:  (2/5)  not much service to speak of.
ENVIRONMENT:  (2/5)  Uncomfortable...
BIG LOCUST'S RECOMMENDATION:  (2/5)  Don't bother.  Not worth the wait.

Sunday, 12 August 2012

W28: So bad that it was funny.


Shop info:
W28
9/F, QRE Plaza, 202 Queen's Road East, Wan Chai

11 August 2012, lunch
$150 per head


If you take trying restaurants you haven't been to as a habit, you'll experience a wide range of emotions in the process - the pleasure of running across good meals, the excitement of finding decent meals at good price, the annoyance of dealing with waiters who don't give a damn, the pain of paying for overpriced meals at sub-par restaurants.

This place, though, has taken it to another level.  This place has left me so shocked that it was funny.  More about that later…

THE ENVIRONMENT
Located on the 9th floor of QRE Plaza in company of other restaurants such as La Cucina Italiana on 21/F, Akita Teppanyaki on 8/F and Zummer on 23/F.  The first impression exiting the lift was that of an elegant, somewhat hip dining room.  Once the staff lead you into the inner parts though, with booth seats and sofas the inner section of the restaurant feels surprisingly crowded.  The booth seats have a strange, unclean feel to it which made me squirm.  Air conditioning was weak.


THE SERVICE
The waitstaff were obviously more interested in their own chit-chat than in serving their customer.  When we walked in nobody was at the door and we had to find a waiter to get a table.  By the time we wanted the bill they were so absorbed in their own cocktail party at the bar that we almost had to dance on our seat to get their attention!  On our way out, they were so excited in their discussion that they didn't even bother to turn around to say goodbye…

Their introduction of the soup of the day, of course, was incomprehensible and the waitress didn't even bother to tell us about the "daily dessert" until we asked.  And then, her mumbling was so quite that I didn't catch much of what she said.

THE FOOD
Seems shocking enough?  The food was definitely more "interesting".  Here goes…



The bread came in an interesting arrangement of dark / light / dark / light.  Normal and whole wheat baguettes, of course.  These came warmed and with a slice of flavourless butter that had a striking resemblance of a slice off an Anchor butter block.  The bread was worse than the butter.  The dehydrated outer layer shouts that it's a few days old, just like those little mermaid baguettes which you'd buy, leave on the dining table and forgot about.  The bread was so dry-aged that the cut surfaces are slightly caved in.  Reheating such a piece of bread, of course, makes no difference - it's still going to be horrid.


Something cream soup, according to the waitress.  This tasted suspiciously like the "white soup" of the "red / white soup" at Hong Kong style "western" restaurants.  A bit more potato-ey and without the typical canned corn and carrot bits.  Quite smooth, but really, that flavour only reminds me of the  soup of the $30 lunch I used to get when in secondary school!

Grilled fillet of sole "Meuniere" with Angel Hair

The fillet of sole was fine.  Still quite HK-western restaurants but the succulent fish went well with the lemon butter sauce (of course, that's a fail safe combination!).  The peripherals, however, were complete failures.  The angel hair was cooked with no seasoning whatsoever.  Bland and tasteless are the only descriptions that I can think of.  It was so bad that it tasted of the starchy leftover water from cooking that angel hair.  I'd even hazard to guess that the water was hardly salted.  Mixing in the lemon butter didn't help much, as after that it tasted of starchy leftover water that has gone sour.  Nicht gute.

The carrots and broccoli weren't any better.  These were simply blanched in boiling water, again without no seasoning and were utterly bland.  Furthermore, the broccoli was in one big lump that you'd have to chop it up yourself.  Frankly, the chef who did these should be sent to wash dishes instead.

As a result, the angel hair, the carrots and the broccoli… were left largely untouched and I left the restaurant still hungry.  It was that bad.


This was almost the sourest and bitterest cup of coffee I've even been served in such a setting.  Way too hot as well.  Thumbs down.

CONCLUSION
Even now, I find it difficult to properly understand this meal.  The setting of the place was that of a mid-to-high-priced restaurant.  Price wasn't cheap, as my fillet of sole lunch costed $118+10%.  Quality was that of a cheap HK-western restaurant (a.k.a. 港式西餐廳).  Service was non-existent.  These were enough strikingly contrasting elements that it takes it beyond annoying or infuriating, and instead made it funny.

This lunch, therefore, was a complete joke.  FML.

My recommendation, therefore, is to avoid this place.  I'm so glad that we didn't try the a la carte "recommended" dishes costing >$300 per dish.  

Oh, by the way, "奶茶咖啡檸茶檸水… 仲有檸蜜".  That's what she said.

Summary (rated 1-5):
FOOD:  (2/5)  Don't expect anything.
SERVICE:  (2/5)  Waitresses don't give a damn.  But at least they didn't pour the coffee on us. 
ENVIRONMENT:  (3/5)  Dirty seats… hmm… 
BIG LOCUST'S RECOMMENDATION:  (2/5)  Don't bother.

Sunday, 5 August 2012

Pastis Bistro Francais: Why did we bother?


Shop Info:
Pastis Bistro Francais
G/F, 65 Wyndham Street, Central

4 August 2012, Lunch
$360 per head

A year or so ago, Locust Tunghok and I first tried this place for lunch.  Back then, we were here for the pint of Kronenbourg and discovered its exquisite Boeuf Bourguignonne and its most delicious bangers and mash.  No, that's not its French name but that's what I like to call it.  Back then the sausage was house made and juicy, the caramelised onion soft and sweet and the mash silky smooth.  We also decided that we will return to try its steak tartare, among other items.

So when I saw advertisement on HKEJ saying this shops is "for let" yesterday, we panicked and decided to come here for lunch immediately.


THE ENVIRONMENT
Located at the turn of Wyndham street, Pastis is small.  The high tables seat approximately 20 excluding the bar and two of the table faces the busy Wyndham Street directly - perfect for the Parisian pastime of people watching and being watched with a pint in your hand, but not so perfect if you intend to have a quiet meal, or if you are concerned with the possibility of getting pneumoconiosis.  Wyndham Street is busy.

That aside, the environment is actually quite cozy and is perfect for spending an afternoon sipping beer / coffee and relaxing.

THE SERVICE
It's easy to be intimidated by the manager / owner and the staff at Pastis, especially if you're Chinese and not used to the French arrogance.  No, perhaps arrogance is not a good description.  The manager and the staff are actually very friendly once you start chatting with them, but they do have this typically French coldness that one might feel difficult to break through.  Worry not.  Talk to them, ask them about the dishes, even ask them to teach you how to read those French names.  Once they start talking they're very friendly and welcoming!

THE FOOD
Unfortunately, the food we had this time was nowhere near as good as those we had a year or so ago.  The manager suggested an off-menu frog legs in place of the escargots we originally wanted, and with that we also had a small sized steak tartare, "bangers and mash" i.e. pork sausages with mashed potato and French lentils, and confit de canard.  Before those, however, I found it disappointing that they only have Stella draught now… no more Kronenbourg… 

Off menu frog legs ($108)

The Frog legs were only mediocre.  As I was busy consuming the steak tartare I only briefly sampled these.  As Locust Tunghok may agree, they were really quite oily.  There was a small swimming pool of oil at the bottom of the plate when we were half way through the dish and the greens on the side ended up being used to mop up the oil.

Steak Tartare coupé au Couteau
Traditional Steak Tartare Served w/ Frites or Green Salad ($108 / $188)

The "or" in the name of the dish was probably misplaced - as we were given both Frites AND greens.  Some may find the seasoning of the steak tartare to be too light, but I found it just right and more subtle than the one at e.g. Bouchon.  Slightly heavy on the salt though…

Saucisses de Toulouse
Pork Sausages served w/ Mashed Potato & French Lentils ($145)

This bangers and mash (yes I like calling them such) was a big disappointment for me, partly because the one I had last time was just so good.  This time, the sausages were quite dry, the skin rather chewy, the onions tasted "sweetened", the mash was dry and bland and probably need triple the butter, double the work put into mashing and a hell lot more salt.  The lentils was a mystery for me.  Why put some rather dry lentils next to some rather dry mash (i.e. more starch) and some rather dry sausages?  Frankly, this dish felt like a patch work - the three elements as they were really didn't work well together.

Confit de Canard
Confit Duck Leg with Carrot Mash & Creamy Mustard Sauce ($198)

The duck confit was not very good.  Meat was dry, skin not sufficiently crispy and had quite a bit of fat underneath.  Nowhere near as bad as the catastrophic one we had at Chez Patrick Deli in Wan Chai though, fortunately!  The carrot mash was quite nice though, especially when eaten with the onion - nice and refreshing!  My biggest problem with this dish was the price.  At $198 (~EUR 20!!) it is not cheap and did not have a quality to match.  Not worth ordering really.

CONCLUSION
We talked with the manager afterwards about the advertisement that concerned us in the first place and he clarified that they do not have any plans of moving soon.  Glad to hear, but frankly it doesn't matter to us as much anymore - the food just isn't as good as it was.  Perhaps the head chef was on leave.  Perhaps they have changed their chef.  That I wouldn't know.  All I know is that for $360 per head this meal was not even satisfactory.  For this kind of price one could easily get lunch at e.g. Madam Sixty Ate where the setting, the food and even the service was far superior.

It pains me to say this, but we won't be coming back.

Summary (rated 1-5):
FOOD:  (2/5)  Poor execution of dishes in general.
SERVICE:  (3/5)  Friendly staff.
ENVIRONMENT:  (3/5)  Can be hot and some might find high tables uncomfortable.
BIG LOCUST'S RECOMMENDATION:  (2/5)  Don’t bother.  Price / quality mismatch.


Further reading:  Crying in the party @ Pastis - by Locust Tunghok

Thursday, 2 August 2012

Hatsu Japanese Restaurant: Maybe cooked food is better?

Shop Info:
Hatsu Japanese Restaurant
G/F, Bank of America Tower, 12 Harcourt Road, Central


1 August 2012, Lunch
$230 per head



UPDATE:  A later visit ordering cooked food gave a much better experience.


I was filled with joy when I learnt a month or so ago that a new Japanese restaurant will be launched near my workplace where the barren dining landscape limits lunch choices to Café de Coral, Maxim MX, McDonald’s and Hokkaido Dairy Farm Milk Restaurant.  So when I discovered that it has opened I waked in without a second thought, on its third day of operation.


THE ENVIRONMENT
With its plain wooden table, leather seats, plenty of sunlight and the rather industrial pebble stone pile wall, Hatsu brings an air of simple refreshing elegance to the rather dull ground floor of the BoA Tower.  On the other hand, similar to the Burger King which occupied the same space a few months ago, the main dining area is quite open, with one side facing the rather busy McDonald’s.  If privacy is a concern or if you feel uneasy dining where lots of people walk by every moment, booking a table with the specific request for a table at the inner side of the premise along the full-height windows facing Cotton Tree Drive would be a good idea.  Traffic outside will unlikely be a significant concern thanks to the dense vegetation of the planters outside.


Be warned, though, that air-conditioning at certain locations may be very strong, such as where I was seated near the entrance…



THE SERVICE
Service was pretty standard here.  The waitresses were courteous and respond promptly when you signal for their attention and the manager came concerned when he noticed that I left half my sashimi untouched – more about that later.


THE FOOD
Some say ordering sashimi / sushi at a “Japanese restaurant” is a dangerous act unless the establishment is traditional Japanese with a Japanese chef at the helm, where chances of survival would be better.  Even I myself have warned friends against doing such a rackless thing.  Yet, this is exactly what I’ve done today – ordering a sashimi & sushi set lunch, but oh my, even the mentality of venturing where no sane person would go, for the sake of truly gauging the merits of this new restaurant, was not enough to prepare me for the shock I received when I saw this:


Sushi & sashimi set ($230)

The prevalence of the colour orange was appalling.  Maybe they have to pay their rent and bills, maybe they think the Hong Kong people like salmon sashimi, but I almost felt cheated that I was given the cheapest cuts possible for a price of $230.  Come on…


Let’s start with the maki rolls and the sushi.  In the front there’s the salmon, Japanese amberjack, tuna, shrimp and octopus.  The salmon was rubbery, amberjack mediocre, tuna not fresh and lacks texture, shrimp was tasteless and octopus… well I don’t usually eat octopus so couldn’t really tell.  Hell, although this is completely not a fair comparison in any sense, look at Locust Tunghok’s recent review of Sushi Xuan.  Although that sushi set was 50% pricier, the difference of quality is the best example of heaven and hell.


The maki rolls...  Salmon and cucumber.  Seriously?  I’ve had cucumber maki rolls at decent sushi restaurant too, such as this one at Sushi Iwa in Tokyo.  That, was a cucumber maki roll, refreshing and sliced up for better crunchiness.  Another version I’ve had at a location I’ve since forgotten had it finely chopped for a completely different texture.  Not this one.  This was a chunck of cucumber wrapped in rice wrapped in nori.  The salmon maki roll… was just that.



The sushi was not appealing, but the sashimi was worse.  The Japanese amberjack was tasteless and rubbery but edible.  The salmon was half-half, as in half of each piece tasted OK whereas the other half had a strange mushy texture.  One can easily buy better salmon sashimi in, for example, CitySuper.  The maguro, or toro as the manager claimed (tuna, anyway), was the worst of the three.  The fishiness of the tuna was not as pungent as the foul prawn sashimi we were served at Kyoto Joe, but bad enough that its non-swallow-able and had to be spit out.  The fishiness almost develops in your mouth, getting more acute with every chew.



How about the salad?  Again freshness was a problem.  Look closely and you’d realize the leaves were withered.  There was also a strange bitterness to the dressing which I couldn’t identify nor like.  This could be a matter of preference though.



The chawanmushi was perhaps the only dish which I marginally liked.  The egg was smooth and cooked just right, although the flavor was weak and lacks the layers of flavor usually found in better versions.  Not surprising since the only ingredients in the chawanmushi was the mushroom as shown, a 1/4 piece of Japanese fishball and a tiny piece of chicken.


The miso soup… I was furious enough by then that I couldn’t recall how it tasted.



Coffee was decent, but the size of the cup and its contrast with the creamer was baffling… 


CONCLUSION
So, this can be taken as the prime example of what not to order at a “Japanese restaurant”.  Had the price been $85, the quality of the food provided would probably have been less infuriating, but I would nonetheless suggest all raw items to be avoided like a plague.  Cooked food?  Maybe on a day when I’m feeling adventurous enough, I’d give those a try.


Summary (rated 1-5):
FOOD:  (2/5)  Cheap ingredients that’s not fresh sold at premium price.
SERVICE:  (4/5)  Friendly staff and proactive manager.
ENVIRONMENT:  (3/5)  Casual dining environment, too open.
BIG LOCUST'S RECOMMENDATION:  (2/5)  Don’t bother.  At least don’t bother with its sushi / sashimi.


Wednesday, 2 May 2012

Amore di Tubino: Love of sheath? eh?

Shop Info:
Amore di Tubino
25-26/F, L'hart, 487-489 Lockhart Road, Causeway Bay

29 April 2012, Lunch
$120 per head


Locust tunghok and I were wandering on the streets on Causeway Bay trying to decide on somewhere for lunch.  The suddenly hot weather has affected our appetite quite a bit but somehow we wanted pasta.  So we decided to try our luck at Ana Oyster & Grill in the restaurant building "Kyoto Plaza".  On our way there, we noticed this seemingly new (to me at least!) restaurant called Amore di Tubino, and decided to give it a go.  Of course, we later realised that this is in fact the same restaurant we've been to and didn't really care much about, with the name changed.

Now I do not have any knowledge of Italian, but Google translate has taught me that the name of the restaurant means "love of sheath".  Eh?  Chinese translation is even worse... "愛護套"... hmm... interesting.  Can someone enlighten me on what the name actually means?

Anyway, when we arrived and asked for the menu to test the water, the waitress shown us a budget lunch menu and the full menu.  Whilst the lunch menu seemed pretty standard, the full menu was rather attractive.  Which is why we decided try.

However, when we were seated, we were told that only the items on the lunch menu is available.  Now, the lunch menu was a tiny menu with a pasta, a lamb, a beef, a chicken and a fish to choose from, or something along those lines.  The crab and king prawn linguini in the main menu and the pizza in the main menu, which were the reasons why I decided to risk it, were of course not on this lunch set list.  Why, for crying out loud, did you not tell us we can only order from the lunch menu?  Or rather, why did you show us a menu which we cannot order from??


I settled for the fish, but unfortunately this extreme disappointment has pretty much set the tone for the meal.


  

Don't be fooled.  Whilst this bread basket looks reasonable its looks were merely a bluff.  The bread is only just considered warm.  We weren't given any olive oil and balsamic vinegar, nor were we given any butter.  Worse, the bread was of CX-flight quality.  That is, the upper crust was slightly crispy slightly hard.  The bottom was rather solid and the core was rather dry.  Now of course this is a cheap lunch set (although I still wanted that linguini...) but how hard can it be to ensure that the bread is suitable for human consumption?  The photo on the right shows how much was left behind.

"Creme of pumpkin soup"

According to the waitress this was "creme of pumpkin soup".  That pathetic blob on top was likely some kind of cream.  The soup itself was quite light (read:  somewhat bland) and not overly filling (read:  thin).  Flavour does somewhat tell that it is a pumpkin soup but was not very vocal about it...

"Talipa" fish

"butter sauce"

That's what the menu says anyway.  I suspect they mean tilapia, which is actually a common name for a group of some 100 species of freshwater fishes from the tilapiine cichlid tribe.  Really should have looked it up before ordering, since according to some website (yea, homework done too late) the fish is rather tasteless itself and usually it's taken as a blank slate for the sauce to shine.  And the sauce in this dish?  A stupid butter sauce.  Which was not a very good sauce at all... didn't even taste of butter.  The photo above, taken immediately after the dish was served, shows the layer forming on top of the sauce -- a tell-tale sign of how long ago that has sat somewhere in the kitchen before it was brought to the table...

Damn... did I mention the fish was overcooked?  And part of it was so thin that the "crust" was thicker than the fish?

"Cheesecake"

Again, this is "dessert of the day", which according to the waitress was a cheesecake.  Cheesecake my arse.  To me that was a poorly made, tasteless sponge cake with some gelatinous stuff on top purporting to be a cheese cake.  Only had one bite.

The verdict

Coffee was very sour, lacks aroma... and in general not suitable for consumption.

So, as a summary:
1)  Misleading us into thinking that the full menu is available, whilst it wasn't.
2)  Bread was cold and of CX quality.
3)  Pumpkin soup was bland.
4)  Fish was horrid.
5)  Coffee sucked.

Enough said.


Summary (rated 1-5):
Food:  (1/5) 
Service:  (2/5)  For misleading us to think that the full menu would be available.  And for not providing much service anyway -- see the butter sauce...
Environment:  (3/5)  Not bad actually, but the background music was quite weird and not suitable for the decor at all...
Big Locust's Recommendation:  (2/5)  Don't bother, really.  It's lunch sets are not pricey, but the quality is horrible.

Tuesday, 28 February 2012

Goccia Ristorante e Bar: Cheap lunch set. Poor quality.


Shop Info:
Goccia Ristorante e Bar
Shop 2, 73 Wyndham Street, Central, HK
http://www.divinogroup.com/restaurants/goccia/about-us/

23 February 2012, Lunch (Restaurant Week HK)
$215 per head

Locust Tunghok and I decided to go for this little restaurant on Wyndham Street for our Restaurant Week Thursday lunch.  Reviews were overwhelmingly positive on the public restaurant review website, so we hoped to be in for a treat.

The establishment has two floors, the ground floor being the bar area and the 2nd floor the restaurant.  I did notice this rather interesting staircase design... ladies with short skirts should be careful when coming down... wait, that's a design feature?  Fine...

Rather depressingly, despite having booked rather early on I was informed that the indoor area of the restaurant was "fully booked" despite having quite a few empty tables and was told to seat at a table in the outdoor area (which I was later told is a SMOKING area).  Fortunately weather was not too bad and warm enough to seat outside -- it wasn't like there was any choice anyway!

That was the first disappointment of the day.  Now the second:  despite having the basil crusted cod fillet on the menu, it wasn't available, and was replaced with grilled salmon.  And they did not tell me when I was presented the menu.  Nay, I caught that change when the waitress was confirming my "fish" order!  Now two things:  1)  I like cod; and 2) I dislike cooked salmon with a passion.  So I ended up with the sirloin steak, same as Locust Tunghok.

Having just looked at the public restaurant review website, I've realised that others were served salmon as well... That doesn't sound like cod has "ran out" as the waitress claimed!  Now, if you do not intended to serve cod, which I understand to be a more expensive fish (?), do not put it on the bloody menu!  Just say you'll serve bloody salmon and I'd have avoided coming in the first place!!  Anyway...

The bread basket (actually a basket, of which I forgot to photo...) was OK.

Wild Mushroom and Black Truffle Soup

The soup was actually quite flavoursome, but I would suggest Goccia to rename it to "chunky mushroom soup".    The mushroom pieces weren't small and the black truffle (paste?  oil?) was good to be seen but didn't really add much to the flavour -- the signature earthy fragrance of the truffle was definitely missing here.

Sirloin Steak with Fontina Cheese and Sauteed Mushroom

Overcooked

If the soup was disappointing, the steak was bad.  It certainly wasn't as disastrous as the one I've had on my own at Craftsteak the day before, which was severely overcooked.  This one was very thin, about 1cm thick I'd reckon, which never bodes well for a steak, and was again overcooked.  As usual we asked for medium-rare, and as shown in the photo, that was closer to medium welldone.  The char-grilled flavour was lacking as well, since the steak was only lightly grilled (yet overcooked?  strange).

The cheese was a nice addition.  Although its flavour can possibly be ignored, it did add smoothness to the steak, which it in itself lacks... Furthermore, the steak came sliced and all the juices seem to be gone... that thing was quite dry.  (Need I say again that steak should be rested before cutting?)

Vanilla creme brulee served with chocolate ice-cream

Molten chocolate ice-cream

The dessert was a further annoyance, although by this time we were almost giving up on the restaurant.  The photo above was taken immediately after the plate arrived, and yes the chocolate ice-cream was half melted when served.  I do seriously wonder how long that plate has been sitting in some obscure corner before it was served to us, and whether the chef has any QC before letting a dish leave the kitchen -- any chef who can allow that half molten crap to be served should be fired.  This should be an unforgivable sin.  It was a horrid view to behold!

The flavour of the chocolate ice-cream was decent though, in fact rather strong, which I liked, but given the shape it was in I really didn't enjoy it at all.

The vanilla creme brulee was again OK, with plenty of vanilla seeds which looked more than it tasted.  Also a tall and thin-ish cup with a not-so-small spoon to eat creme brulee with was a bad idea.  The chef / waitstaff need to put more thought into how to serve and present their food!  The supposedly hard caramel was somewhat under-burnt (how I hope this is evened out with the overcook steak...) and not as crispy as I would have preferred.

Service was again mediocre, with no waitress to be seen when we wanted to pay and leave.  Many thanks to the guy at the pizza oven who helped us to find one... we could have been stuck there for much longer otherwise!

I do like to say again that I could not understand the rationale of these restaurants of participating in the Restaurant Week.  If all the reviews on OR are positive, there must be some good to the restaurant (oh wait some are free PR meals?), yet it has ruined its image to us by serving this obviously sub-par meal.  Good enough for the price, perhaps, and meeting price limitation might well be the reason why the cut of meat was poor (couldn't explain the half molten choco ice-cream or the overcooked steak though!) but that's no excuse for a restaurant to serve such poor quality food when they should be able to do better.  To me, it's always a choice of either raising the bloody price to serve a decent meal or to not participate at all!

So for me, unfortunately, I will not come back.

Oh, and for $290, slightly more than the price we paid here, we got a much better meal at Chez Patrick Restaurant.


Summary (rated 1-5):
Food:  (2/5)  Look at that steak.
Service:  (2/5)  No reasonable waitress should serve a half-molten scoop of ice-cream!
Environment:  (2.5/5)  Despite indicating that we wanted non-smoking, that wasn't accommodated and a guy who seemed to be the boss / boss's friend was there smoking.  Duh.
Big Locust's Recommendation:  (2/5)  Don't bother.

Wednesday, 22 February 2012

Craftsteak: CRAP-I-stepped-on-a-landmine-STEAK


Shop Info:
Craftsteak Open Fire Cooing
29 Elgin Street, Soho, Central
http://www.diningconcepts.com.hk/craftsteak/index.php

22 February 2012, Lunch (Restaurant Week HK)
$316

The second lunch with Me and Myself during the Restaurant Week was at this restaurant on Elgin Street, quite near Bouchon which we liked a lot.  Unfortunately, this turned out to provide me the opportunity for a change back to normal - to the negative reviews I'm more used to writing...


The first sign of trouble became apparent after I sat down at the table right next to the door.  Why I was given that table where I experienced a miniature tornado whenever anybody comes in despite me being the first customer to arrive is beyond my understanding – there were empty tables throughout lunch.  Anyway, delivery after delivery of raw materials: canisters of coke, beef, and whatever else, kept coming through the door, throughout lunch service.  Perhaps they can arrange their deliveries better so their customers won’t have to endure deliveries squeezing by so many times?

Then it was the chaos in understanding the booking.  As far as I know, and as far as my previous 3 Restaurant Week meals told me, those who booked under Restaurant Week will be presented the RW menu.  Not here.  I had to ask the waitress repeatedly before she realised “oh!  Restaurant week!” and gave me the RW menu…

Bread – telling me that the chef don’t give a damn what they serve their customers

If the previous made me worried, the bread they served confirmed that I’ll be in to endure a rough lunch.  Look at that cheap, blatantly purchased bread, slightly warmed and served, which just tasted like those served in HK-style “Western” restaurants.  The pate next to it was a mystery.  I wasn’t told what it is but it tasted of canned tuna.  That “pate” was very solid (as in hard) but flavour was weak.  Worse still, whoever filling that little container with that pate obviously wasn’t paying attention, as the outside of the container was very greasy and not wiped clean.  Thus I ended up with a sticky finger…

French Onion Soup and Gratinated Cheese – not bad

The onion soup was actually decent.  Portion was big but the flavour was there, albeit somewhat  weak.  Not as good as the one we had on Monday at JAR though, which was much stronger in flavour.

Grilled Flank Steak, French Fries, Sauce Bearnaise – overcooked and burnt

Really quite burnt...

... and quite overcooked

Sent back…

The steak, though, was a complete and utter mess.  The cut of meat was haphazard – a long and thin strip.  The steak itself was severely overcooked.  I asked for it to be done medium-rare, and it came well done and burnt – don’t tell me those are grill marks, because it was obviously burnt and taste very bitter.  The inside was almost cooked through with only a slight bit of pink, and it was dry.  The fries on the side?  Well, those looked like cheap packaged fries to me, and definitely not house made.  Tasted much better than the steak though.  I ended up giving up and sent most of it back (see photo…)

Vanilla Ice Cream – or vanilla essence ice-cream

This is probably one of the most un-imaginative dessert I see on the Restaurant Week menus.  Nonetheless, had the ice-cream been good, all would be fine.  It wasn’t though.  Portion was extremely big (the scoop was almost the size of my fist!) but from the colour alone one can tell it’s crap.  Its yellowish tinge shouts “vanilla essence” and it tasted of exactly that, despite the black spots which could be vanilla seeds.  The ice-cream itself wasn’t smooth and flavour was obviously artificial.  Again only finished half.

Latte ($38 + 10%) – worst I’ve had in quite a while

Ordered latte, which arrived foamy and very light in colour.  Can tell immediately it is crap and it was.  Almost no coffee flavour at all except a bit of bitterness.  Foam on top was detergent-like.  Worst latte I’ve had in a long while (the previous that was as bad was Starbucks).  Oh and it’s more expensive than the one I had at Rabbithole which was in a completely different league.

Sometimes I do feel that restaurants like these need to distinguish between quantity and quality.  Providing large portions of poorly made food to customers would only elevate their anger and not mitigate anything, especially when the customers do not want to waste food.  At $248 + 10% the lunch set wasn’t cheap at all and as far as I know, is higher priced than their normal lunch sets.  That wasn’t matched by the quality of the food at all.  This is supposed to be Restaurant Week and no GROUPON budget meal!  I do understand that this price is a bit low for a good cut of meat but at the very least it should warrant proper execution.

Had they price it at $98 I won’t be as furious, because that’s about how much I felt this set is worth – but I’ll know better than giving it a try at that price!

When I left, I finally noticed the two (quite) young “chef” working at the grill… where’s the head chef?  And where’s your QC?  I still couldn’t believe any reasonable chef could send that burnt piece of steak…

Summary (rated 1-5):
Food:  (1/5)  Failed in almost every dish.  Except the mediocre onion soup.
Service:  (3/5)  Nice enough staff but not very attentive.
Environment:  (2.5/5)  Actually not bad but I was given maybe the worst table in the restaurant.
Big Locust's Recommendation:  (2/5)  Don’t bother.  It’s not exactly cheap and quality doesn’t match the price.

Sunday, 19 February 2012

Oolaa: Oocrap!

Shop Info:
Oolaa
G/F, Centre Stage, Bridges Street, Soho, Central
http://www.casteloconcepts.com/locations/hong-kong/oolaa-hong-kong

18 February 2012, Lunch
~$260 per head


As the title of this post might suggest, this is yet another instalment of Locusts' eating-adventure-gone-bad.  On this cool Saturday afternoon, we decided to visit this rather remote establishment near Central.  Located to the west of Aberdeen Road and accessible via Stanton Street, the "Soho" in the address is rather questionable.  However, other than that one might find it difficult to describe this area.

The restaurant is much larger than we imagined (or realised, since we've walked past this place a few times already) and comprise of a bar, dining area, private dining and an outdoor area, which occupies almost the entire ground floor of the Centrestage Towers.  We were reassured by the fact that the establishment was packed with people and went for it.

To go straight to the point, 1) there was almost no service; 2) food was crap; 3) overpriced.

For me, the only saving grace was the pint of Kronenbourg 1664 and the half pint of Asahi, which were nice and not often available as draught in Hong Kong.

To begin with, Nobody gave a damn when we entered the restaurant.  Waitresses (and there were many) walked by and none thought of at least checking out what the two customers who just came in wanted.  Find us a table, anyone?  Perhaps being Chinese in a restaurant where almost all diners are Gwei-los surely didn't help, but I do consider finding your customers a table or telling them you don't have one to be basic hospitality.

After stopping a lady who seemed to be the manager for a table and being shoo-ed off to a high table in the bar (nobody ever asked what we wanted - we were here for freggin LUNCH and there were obviously tables in the dining area!), we asked for a menu.  And I thought it's a common practice to show your customers the menu as see what they want.  Anyway, we had to ask two separate wait-staff and finally got to appreciate the menu after a good 5-minute wait.

Now, it would be normal to expect that the place was understaffed and the house crew were stretched too thin to provide any quality service -- no, the place was freggin SWARMING with wait-staff, most appearing to be extremely busy, or at least trying to seem to be extremely busy by wandering around all the time.  WTF, really?

Steak Tartare with Roquefort foam, quails egg, Turkish toasts and a gazpacho ‘shot’ ($160) -- worst I've ever had...


This steak tartare was the worst I've ever had.  By far.  Its problems are many:

1)  The freggin patty / dollop / pile of meat was almost certainly minced in a mincer instead of chopped, as it should be.
2)  Quite a bit of white tendon bits...
3)  That pile of meat has definitely sat in a cylindrical container for ages -- long enough that even with the help of a fork and a knife, I had difficulty breaking it up.  It was basically a solid lump of mushy meat.
4)  Why I have to break it up?  Well, the damn thing isn't seasoned AT ALL.  The gherkin was on the side, the cheese foam was on the side, the mustard was on the side.
5)  I had to chop-my-own-gherkin.
6)  Mustard is of the cheapest, supermarket variety -- much like those they use on cheap hotdog stands.
7)  The toasts were rock-hard.  And they were dry.

The list can easily go on.  And come on, a tiny pile of poorly-made steak tartare for $160?  Are you serious??

Linguini alle Vongole with fresh clams, scorched tomatoes, saffron; in a white wine garlic sauce ($130) -- rubbery clams

Locust Tunghok's main, which I had a few bites.  Again very poorly executed and not balanced at all.  The clams were FUBB (i.e. f-ed up beyond believe) -- so overcooked that half the clams were separated from their shells.  For a while, we thought the shells were there for decorative purpose only.  The meat, of course, was rubbery and tasteless.  Except for a few pieces which had a disturbingly prominent fishy after-taste...

And the taste.  Saffron?  White Wine?  Garlic?  I tasted none of those.  The overwhelming flavour in the pasta was of the spiciness of chilli.  Nothing else.  The linguini itself might have been al dente-ish, but that didn't really help much.

Eggs Benedict - 2 poached eggs; with citrus hollandaise (OPTION:  smoked salmon & buttered baby spinach) ($95) -- WTF?

Again, a massive screw-up.  The looks, at first, might be promising.  The poached egg, at least, look somewhat proper.  But no, this Eggs Benedict was a mess.  Why:

1)  hollandaise sauce can only be enjoyed by the eye -- it was basically tasteless.
2)  the smoked salmon seems to have been unpacked, defrosted and left in the kitchen for hours.  Texture was mushy and it was basically falling apart.
3)  what are those stalks doing there?  I love these kind of stalks stir-fried with garlic, Chinese style.  Not in my Eggs Benedict thank you.  And this veg just didn't work with the salmon at all.
4)  I couldn't taste the *buttered* part at all...
5)  Whilst the English muffin in this looked fine (it was still a bit dry), the bottom of the other muffin (there were two, as normal) was absolutely solid.  So tough that I couldn't even cut it with my knife.  I wonder how long that has been aged...

Luckily, the poached egg was OK, with a perfectly runny yolk.  But then, given the other screw-ups, that really didn't compensate enough... And come on, at $95 I do expect to have some sides to go with this, or given that they charge for the sides ($25-30), at least some plating?  Presentation was just that, 2 Eggs Benedict on a large and rather empty plate.

When we left, I couldn't shake this thought off me:  perhaps, perhaps, this place is so full because this is a convenient place for a drink for the foreigners living above?  Unlike the food, their beer was decent.  Having sampled a bit of breakfast menu, starter and pasta, and given the excessive price tag, I really wouldn't have the stupidity to come again, and I would suggest you to avoid this place as well.

Summary (rated 1-5):
Food:  (2/5)  The beer certainly helped.  Otherwise I would have given a 1.5, if not a 1.
Service:  (1.5/5)  Simply horrid.
Environment:  (3.5/5)  Actually quite like the ambience and the ample sunlight in the restaurant.  Bit too noisy though.
Big Locust's Recommendation:  (2/5)  Don't Bother.  No point wasting your hard-earned cash here.